1. Introduction
Sheep farming is one of the largest agricultural branches in the Republic of Kazakhstan and is highly economically important. Among farm animals, sheep occupy the top place in the variety of products manufactured. Muldasheva, Toxanbayeva ( 1 ), ( 2 ) have noted that sheep breeding provides the national economy with a sufficient amount of wool, sheepskin, and leather and supplies the population with food products: milk, meat, cheese, and feta cheese. Parasitic infections such as protozoa and worms can significantly damage animal breeding; this pathogenesis of these infections causes a significant reduction in productivity and the immunity of young animals, which often causes more loss than mortality ( 3 , 4 ).
Knowing the types of parasitic pathogens and their epizootological characteristics in specific climatic and production conditions is necessary to control various infections. Moreover, treatment plans based on these principles have a synergistic effect ( 5 , 6 ). Melikyan ( 7 ) reported that sheep mortality due to parasitic diseases could vary from 13.3 to 50%. Sariev, Kereev ( 8 ) announced that the loss due to mortality is a smaller part of the economic damage caused by parasitic contamination, and a large amount of loss to livestock farmers is caused by the latent effects of contamination on the productivity of livestock products. It should be noted that sheep health is related to immune protection, which is weakened in conditions of parasitic infection ( 3 , 4 ). Kazakhstan has a Semipalatinsk nuclear test site, which was used for 40 years (1949-1989). It had suffered more than 450 aboveground and underground explosions. Radiometric control shows a high level of radiological pollution at all control points: the exposure dose rate ranged from 0.08 to 032 μSv/h. The Semipalatinsk test site still has a harmful impact on human and animal health. For example, the rural spontaneous pastures organized at landfill lands near the test site affected the immune, bone, and reproductive systems changing metabolism processes ( 3 , 9 ).
So far, many researches have shown that susceptibility to Eimeria infection increases if the immunity of ruminants is reduced. Kozhabaev, Suleimanov ( 10 ), ( 11 ) have noted that lambs are more susceptible to infection compared to older sheep. The prevalence of infection in sheep flocks has a pattern that its level increases in spring and autumn and decreases in winter. Examination of the infection shows that the infection is often observed in a mixed form of two to five species of Eimeriaspp. in sheep. More mixed invasions by different helminths (gastrointestinal tract helminths and Eimeria spp.) were found in lambs aged 3–4 months in East Kazakhstan. Gastrointestinal parasites in lambs often include Strongylusspp, Strongyloidspp. And Eimeria species ( 12 - 14 ). Therefore, the prevention and treatment of parasitic diseases in farm animals have a significant place in the system of veterinary practices ( 9 ). Due to the contamination of radioactive radiation in this region and the adverse effect on the immune system of livestock in the region, parasitic diseases are common. Antiparasitic drugs are necessary cures to preserve healthy livestock in the conditions of radioactive pollution, but this cannot be done without a detailed study of the regional parasites' epizootiology. For this purpose, in the present study, different treatment methods using antiparasitic drugs were evaluated in the control of Strongyloides spp. and Eimeria spp. infection.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Sampling and Design of the Study
The experiment lasted from 2017 to 2019 at East Kazakhstan farm manufacturers "Zhartas" (Tarbagatai district), "Әzbergen" (Abai district), "Altai" (Semey city), "Nurzhan" (Beskaragai district), "Aydar" (Ayagoz region). In the current experiment, 3 groups of lambs were evaluated, including 30 lambs of 5 to 6 months. After determining the degree of contamination of the lambs based on the coprological test based on Fulborn's method, the infected lambs were divided into 3 groups considering the body weight and degree of contamination. The first was the control (without any treatment), and the other two were treated with different designs.
2.2. Experimental Treatment Design
The treatment groups in this research were divided into two groups that were treated with 2 broad-spectrum antiparasitic compounds in the form of tablets and a mineral-salt cube. Treatment schemes were provided according to the patents of Akhmetsadykov, Nur ( 15 ), ( 16 ). Pills of the anti-helmintic drug (Table 1) were tested on the first experimental animal group spontaneously infested with Strongyloides spp. and Eimeria spp. So, the oral free-feeding antiparasite drug (pill dosage of 4 pills per 20 kg of weight) was introduced to the first group. The second experimental group got the mineral-salt cube with the antiparasite effect created by was added to the diet of the sheep according to Akhmetzhanova, Shabdarbaeva ( 16 ), ( 17 , 18 ). It not only had disinfestation action but also served as mineral feeding and improved meal absorption (Table 2). The experimental and control lambs were kept together in a stall and fed green mass and compound feed. The results of the treatment and prevention actions were examined on the 7th day after anti-wormed treatment was conducted on the animals in the experiment with the control group's data.
Сomponent | wt.% |
---|---|
Albendazole | 0-30.0 |
Pyrantel | 20.0-30.0 |
Ivermectin | 0.5-5.0 |
Phenasal (niclosamide) | 5.0-20.0 |
Horse sorrel fruit powder | 5.0-20.0 |
The powder of the aerial part of the lubaznica vulgaris | 5.0-20.0 |
Sucrose | 5.0-15.0 |
Starch | 20.0-50.0 |
Polyvinylpyrrolidone | 1.0-5.0 |
Сomponent | wt.% |
---|---|
Albenvet 360 | 0.8-1.0 |
Trimeratinvet 270 | 1.2-1.3 |
Starch | 3.8-5.9 |
Feed salt | 72.0-74.0 |
2.3. Evaluation of Treatment Effectiveness
In order to evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of the treatment methods used in the investigated groups, the spectrum of parasitic infection was examined using complete and incomplete worm dissection methods and intra-vital studies. Matrices of a complete helminthological autopsy were preserved with Barbagallo liquid (the 3% formalin solution in the isotonic sodium chloride solution) and labeled in a glass jar.
Coprological studies were done based on the Fuller Bon method. Stool samples (3 grams) are kept in a 2.5% potassium dichromate solution. Each stool sample was ground in a porcelain cup with 15-20 ml of water, and after filtering, it was centrifuged (5 minutes; 1000-1500 rpm). The supernatant was drained, and zinc chloride or lead nitrate solutions with a specific gravity of 1598 and 1500 were added. The pellet was thoroughly mixed and centrifuged for 1 min at 1000 rpm. The upper layer was removed from the liquid with a wire loop, transferred to a slide plate, a drop of distilled water was added, covered with a cover slip, and then a microscopic examination was done.
The infection intensity was determined by the formula (1):
A – The number of infected animals;
B – The number of examined animals.
2.4. Statistical Analysis
The SPSS20.0 was used to compare the effectiveness of treatment methods. The t-test and one-way analysis of variance was performed to test the difference between the methods used and the level of parasitic infection (P≤0.05).
3. Results and Discussion
The Semipalatinsk side of the experiment is still a radioactive wasteland. The protective immune response is reduced due to radiation; therefore, invasive diseases can cause significant damage, as Ilyazov ( 3 ) noted. Melnychuk and Antipov ( 19 ) emphasized that radioactive incursions cause great economic damage to animal husbandry worldwide. In this case, our goal was to investigate the treatment methods and the effectiveness of the drugs used in this area in sheep infected with parasites. Millions of animals are annually treated and prevented to limit invasion, reduce economic losses, and gradually recover process. 9 species of Strongyloides and 5 species of eimeria were found in sheep in the omasum, abomasum, small and large intestines: in omasum-Haemonchuscontortus, Ostertagiacircumcincta, in abomasum and duodenum — Nematodirusspathiger, in small intestine-Bunostomumtrigonocephalum, Trichostrongyluscolumbriformis, T. axei, Oesophagostomumvenulosum, Strongyloidespapillosus, in the large intestine – Chabertiaovina and 5 types of eimeria (E. arloingi, E. ninaekohljakimovae, E. Parva, E. faurei, E. аhsata) were found ( 19 , 20 ).
In this study, lambs infected with parasites in eastern Kazakhstan were tested. Significant infection of lambs, especially in the conditions of the former Semipalatinsk polygon, we noted: the infection of sheep at the age of 5-6 months with different intensity of infection varied from 70 to 100%. Clinical signs such as depression and loss of appetite were recorded in lambs, body temperature change in infected sheep was not significant, but in some cases, it increased to 41-40.5ºC, and the feces contained mucus and blood streaks.
According to the study, the minimum infestation was fixed at the "Zhartas" farm of the Tarbagatai district and the "Aydar" farm of the Ayagoz district. Furthermore, the maximum infestation points were detected at the "Nurzhan" farm in the Beskaragai district. In total, 1200 sheep (80%) had Strongyloides-eimeriotic invasion. Strongyloides-eimeriotic infestation of sheep at the zone of minimal radiation risk amounted to 66.7% ( 19 ).
The efficacy of these measures largely depends on the quality of antiparasite drugs and the perfection of the methods of their use. Therefore, developing new antiparasite drugs with high efficacy as a treatment drug and economic action is an urgent task of veterinary science ( 19 - 21 ). In this regard, several antiparasitic drugs with a broad spectrum were used in two forms to make antiparasitic drugs more effective and easier to use.
The supervision was carried out at all stages of the drug preparation. Next, the developed drug was studied for anti-helmintic activity. The veterinary composition was administered orally once with the dosage: of 4 pills (2.0 g of granulate) per 20 kg of live weight of sheep. The autopsy and parasite egg counting results showed that all the lambs in the control group were infected with helminths and Eimeria spp. Nematodes, Strongyloides, and Eimeria spp. Predominated among nematodes. In the experimental groups, a 100% effect was obtained.
The developed mineral-salt cube showed its efficacy with simultaneously anti-helminth and anti-eimeria action. Using a mineral-salt cube showed its effective action against mixed invasions caused by helminths and Eimeria spp. It was used for preventive measures. Studies that began 10, 20, and 30 days after this part of the experiment showed that the mineral-salt cube significantly reduces the number of helminths and Eimeria spp. in sheep (P≤0.05). It must be noted that the control group's animals demonstrated a total (92.18%) infestation of both Eimeriaspp and Strongyloides (Table 3).
Sheep farms | Mean EPG value before/after treatment | Efficacy (%) |
---|---|---|
Mineral-salt cube | 1580/124 | 92.18% |
Tablets | 1648/235 | 85.74% |
In treating sheep parasites, ivermectin, levamisole, albendazole, closantel, and monopantel are available. IVM (macrocyclic lactone) and ABZ (benzimidazole) are more commonly used and have a more appropriate effect ( 22 ). Although extensive studies have shown that Trichostrongylidae infestations have shown resistance to IVM and ABZ, research on antiparasitic resistance is underway worldwide ( 23 ). Infestation of sheep with Eimeria spp. and Strongyloides spp. in the conditions of the ex-Semipalatinsk test-side region is enormous. The highest levels of prevalence and infection intensity in animals were recorded under 6 months. The developed treatment drug schemes have such advantages as a broad spectrum of action and synergism action of the drug components on the helminths infestations.
Authors' Contribution
Study concept and design: O. A.
Acquisition of data: S. D.
Analysis and interpretation of data: A. A.
Drafting of the manuscript: S. T.
Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: A. A.
Statistical analysis: S. D.
Administrative, technical, and material support: A. Y.
Ethics
All experiments were conducted according to the Ethical Protocol approved by the Shakarim State University of Semey Ethics Committee.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References
- Muldasheva AK, Toxanbayeva BO, Ospanov AB, Zhakupova GN, Bostanova SK. Study of the composition and properties of sheep milk in Northern Kazakhstan. EurAsian J Biosci. 2019; 13(2):1997-2000.
- Pozharskiy A, Khamzina A, Gritsenko D, Khamzina Z, Kassymbekova S, Karimov N, et al. SNP genotyping and population analysis of five indigenous Kazakh sheep breeds. Livest Sci. 2020; 241:104252.
- Ilyazov R. Veterinary radiological consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. Vet Stanica. 2016; 47(1):11-24.
- Kryvda M. Analyze of the disorders in reproductive function of mares with latent form of the herpesvirustipe-1. Science Messages of the LNUVMBT SZ Gzhytskyj. 2016; 18:167-70.
- Kartashov S, Klychev E. Method for preparation of feed drug mixtures with anthelmintics. Rossiĭskiĭ Parazitologicheskiĭ Zhurnal. 2018; 1:70-5.
- Zhantelieva LO, Shabdarbaeva GS, Ibazhanova AS, Kenzhebekova ZZ, Balgimbaeva AI. The most common helminthiasis among sheep in Kazakhstan is pathological morphology. KazNAU Res. 2018; 2:63-72.
- Melikyan EL. Coccidiosis of small ruminants in the Armenian SSR. 1953.
- Sariev N, Kereev A, Nadirova G. Helmintosis of small cattle animals and measures of them militant. In VI Intern Sci and PractConf Modern Sci. 2019;306-7.
- Akhmetzhanova AE, Dyusembaev ST, Serikova AT, Iminova DE. Development of a mineral-salt cube with anti-helminth and radioprotective effects. Bul State Univ Shakarim Semey. 2019; 2:392-4.
- Kozhabaev M, Suleimanov MZ, Berdiculov MA, Karataev S, Djusubbekova NM, Tuganbaev A. Invasion of sheep by strongilates in the conditions of the South Kazakhstan. Theory Pract Parasitic Anim Dis. Vet Sci. 2013; 14:168-71.
- Mohamaden WI, Sallam NH, Abouelhassan EM. Prevalence of Eimeria species among sheep and goats in Suez Governorate, Egypt. Int J Vet Sci Med. 2018; 6(1):65-72.
- Abdybekova AM, Sultanov AA, Dzhusupbekova NM, Abdibayeva AA, Zhaksylykova AA, Kerimbaeva RA, et al. Parasites of farmed marals in Kazakhstan. Small Rumin Res. 2017; 153:142-5.
- Berkinbai O, Baitursiniv KK, Asanova GN, Ozbekov AB. Investigation in sheep with monoinvasiun by eimeria in the South Kazakhstan. Kazakh Biol Sci. 2012; 4:78-88.
- Sun P, Wronski T, Bariyanga JD, Apio A. Gastro-intestinal parasite infections of Ankole cattle in an unhealthy landscape: An assessment of ecological predictors. Vet Parasitol. 2018; 252:107-16.
- Akhmetsadykov NN, Nur K, Khusainov DM, Shabdarbaeva GS, Akhmetsadykova SN, Amirgaziev EK, et al. Preliminary patent of the Republic of Kazakhstan. 2005.
- Akhmetzhanova AE, Shabdarbaeva GS, Dyusembaev ST. Emeriosis-strongyloid infestations in sheep in southern Kazakhstan and eastern Kazakhstan. Barnaul Russia: XIV International Scientific and Practice Conferention Innovations in Science and Practice; 2019.
- Serikova AT, Dyusembaev ST, Iminova DE, Zheksenaeva AB, Akhmetzhanova AE. Radioprotective feed mixtures for farm animals and birds raised in the former shiap zone. Intern SciPract Conf. 2019;47-9.
- Shabdarbaeva GS, Khusainov DM, Dyusembaev ST, Turganbaeva GE, Ibazhanova AS, Balgimbaeva AI, et al. Utility Model Patent of the Republic of Kazakhstan Antiparasitic veterinary drug. 2018.
- Melnychuk V, Antipov A. Epizootic situation and peculiarity the course nematodes of the digestive canal of sheep of the in the conditions of economies Kyev region. Sci J Vet Med. 2019; 1(149):75-84.
- Galiya A, Almagul U, Merey Z, Kanatzhan K. Features Of Eimeria-Strongyloid Invasion In Sheepsouth Kazakhstan. Nat Volatiles Essent Oils J. 2021;1001-9.
- Khalikov SS, Lokshin BF, Ilyin MMJ, Varlamova AI, Arkhipov IA. Solid dispersions of benzimidazole preparations in parasitology. International Scientific Conference of the Theory & Practice of the antiparasitic treat Moscow Russia. 2019;663-70.
- Kļaviņa A, Keidāne D, Grasberga MB, Kovaļčuka L. Most Common Antiparasitic Drug Usage Mistakes in Sheep Farms in Latvia. Nature Research Centre, Young Academy of Lithuanian Academy of Sciences, Scandinavian-Baltic Society for Parasitology: Scandinavian-Baltic Society for Parasitology, abstract Book, Vilnius, Lithuania; 2021.
- Papadopoulos E, Gallidis E, Ptochos S. Anthelmintic resistance in sheep in Europe: a selected review. Vet Parasitol. 2012; 189(1):85-8.